Class of 2016
- Brady Helinski-Stevenson University Baseball
- Jaelyn Belt-Bowie State University Track & Field/Softball
- Dami Adekunjo-Tennessee Tech Football
Class of 2017
- Dayvon Cuffey-Mercy College Basketball
- Kayla Briles-Stevenson Softball
- Caitlyn Shacklock-Wesley College Soccer
- Megan Shacklock-Wesley College Soccer
- Katelyn Watson-Wesley College Basketball
- Troy Smoot-Albright College Basketball
- Hannah Eslick-George Washington University Softball
- Sammy Levy-Fairmont State Football
- Joshua Watson-York College Track & Field
- Aaron Watson-George Mason Track & Field
Class of 2018
- Markus Sidwell-Lycoming College Football & Lacrosse
- Victory Ho-AACC Lacrosse
- Jamal Peterson-Saint Anselm College Football
- Gracie Culley-AACC Softball
- Boluwatife Toriola-Frostburg State University Track & Field
- Tori Cain-AACC Volleyball
- Tierra Harris-Neumann University Basketball
- David Kates-LA Pierce CC Football
- Nick Maddox-Fairmont State Football
- Sylvia Frye-AACC Softball
Class of 2019
- Kara Dietrich-Wesley College Lacrosse
- Jessica Harris-North Country CC Basketball
- Morgan Duly-AACC Soccer
- Hannah Gartner-AACC Soccer
- Diana Philpot-Salisbury Track & Field
- Rhoda Alaban-Tafan-St. Francis University Track & Field
- Braeden Cavey-AACC Basketball
- Jordan Fangman-Stevenson University Softball
- Shianne Turner-Limestone College Softball
- Brooke McCormick-Wesley College Softball
- Alyssa Begunich-AACC Soccer & Lacrosse
- Chloe Augustin-AACC Soccer
- Tyrell Francis-Maryland Prep Football